What happens when your zip code is erased? Where do you go? What do you do? Your home and your community, according to the post office, no longer exist. This is the circumstance in which we find Fern, the lead character in the 2020 film, Nomadland.
Fern is in her early sixties. Her husband has recently died and she answers the challenge of where to go and what to do by packing up a van and hitting the road. Fern becomes a nomad and she takes us on the journey into her new life.
This film is called Nomadland, but it could well have been called True Grit, because that is what Fern demonstrates as she adjusts to her new way of life.
It has been said that Frances McDormand is one of the most accomplished actresses of her generation. This film proves the truth of that statement. She is brilliant. In the opening scenes when she goes through her stored possessions, she has me close to tears. She holds her husband's jacket and her face is a subtle study in grief.
From that moment we understand she is not simply leaving a ghost town behind. She is leaving, or at least trying to leave, profound grief.
In the clip (below) at a nomad community, we get a glimpse of the emotional motivation behind Fern's journey.
Near the end of the film one of her fellow nomads explains that being on the road means never having to say goodbye. We realize at this point that Fern is on the road not only because it is an answer to her economic situation, but also because staying hurts too much.
One of her friends, a fellow nomad, has a terminal cancer diagnosis. She has decided she would rather be on the road than in a hospital waiting to die.
The magic in this movie resides not only in McDormand's performance. It rests also in her fellow 'actors'. Almost all of them are not acting. They are truly nomads. They live on the road. They are part of a mobile community that travels from place to place, a kind of underground society of people who, for one reason or another, have taken up anchor and have decided to keep moving.
To be sure, the motivation for all of them seems to be essentially economic. The first stop Fern makes is at a campground near an Amazon warehouse. She arrives at night and the next morning goes to work at the warehouse. It's Christmas. Amazon needs seasonal workers.
We go in the warehouse with Fern. We watch her packing Amazon boxes.
So that's what it's like, I thought as I watched Fern pack a box and put an Amazon seal on it. I order from Amazon all the time and don't think much about the people who pack those boxes.
We meet Fern's coworkers. These are actual Amazon seasonal employees. One of them, Linda May, is someone Fern has met previously.
After work Linda May goes back to Fern's van and Fern explains how she has modified the vehicle to be a living space. There's a stove and cabinets. A sleeping space. A few treasures saved from her former life.
When Fern is at a store she runs into someone from her previous life, a woman with two daughters. The woman invites Fern to stay with the family. One of the children states, "Mom says you're homeless."
Fern answers, "No, I'm not homeless. I'm houseless. It's not the same thing, is it?"
Throughout the movie Fern has a number of opportunities to leave the nomad life. She is invited to stay at her sister's. She is invited to stay at the home of a fellow nomad who has settled down. In each case she chooses to move on.
She learns life skills from her fellow nomads. She learns how to barter. How to care for her van. All the while we fear for Fern's safety, a woman alone. Every now and then it seems she also has a thought about her vulnerability, but she puts her trust in her own skills and in the community of nomads who travel the roads with her.
The nomads are not freeloaders. They are survivors. When Fern's van breaks down and she needs $2300 to fix it, she calls her sister for a loan, not a handout. Here is the scene where the mechanic advises her to sell the van.
This movie struck home with me because it is made so well, because the acting is brilliant, and because it is real. I remembered what one of my children said to me after she had bought a small camper.
"If I'm ever homeless," my child said, "I'll have a place to stay."
Nomadland showed me exactly how that would work out. I don't think many people plan to be homeless...or, as Fern says, houseless.
One of Fern's fellow nomads goes to the Social Security office to ask about benefits. She is 62 and learns that her monthly benefit would be $550. She realizes she can't live on that. Then she hears of a nomad community where cheap RV living is possible on BLM (Bureau of Land Management) land.
This is a great movie, but not a perfect movie. I love good writing so I always consider the script. While most of the film has a real feel...indeed is real because some of the people speak for themselves...some of it is scripted. I take issue with at least two parts of that script.
Fern goes to Amazon because it's Christmas and there is a need for seasonal workers. However, the filmmakers play up the fact that it's Christmas in order to emphasize Fern's solitude. They even have her softly singing a Christmas carol to herself.
We don't need Christmas to feel Fern's solitude. That's an unnecessary attempt to manipulate our feelings and I don't believe it belongs in the movie.
Also, when Fern runs into the mother with her two daughters (referenced earlier in this blog) one of the girls quotes Macbeth's soliloquy: "Tommorrow, and tommorrow, and tommorrow..."
The script writer is telling us how to feel about Fern's nomad life. In such a 'real' movie the scene stands out as artificial.
Those two notes aside, the film is wonderful. Unforgettable. McDormand turns in one of the best performances of her life, I think, and that's saying something.
Besides McDormand, David Strathairn turns in an excellent performance.
Some Data Points:
The movie is based on a book, Nomadland: Surviving America in the Twenty-First Century* by Jessica Bruder. Bruder lived the nomad life for several months as research for her book.
McDormand has credit as a producer of the film.
The following is from IMDB:
Director: ChloΓ© Zhao
Writers: ChloΓ© Zhao, Jessica Bruder
Stars: Frances McDormand, David Strathairn, Linda May
I watched the movie on Netflix
Rating: 95/100
Originally posted through scrobble.life/movies.
Dear @agmoore !
I thought Americans living in trailers were the poorest class in America! This is the first time I've seen them wandering around as seasonal workers!
Do you want to be nomad?
Hello @goldgrifin007,
There are a lot of very poor people in the U.S. A lot of them would love to have a camper. The poorest of the poor live on the street, in tents. It takes money to keep up a camper. First of all, you have to own the camper. Then you need gas, and if it breaks down you need to fix it. But yes, many people living on a tight budget find camper life to be more affordable.
I love campers, but for fun, not for a lifestyle. Some campers are quite luxurious and cost upwards of $100,000. The people in the movie probably did not have one of those campers.
https://mgerwingarch.com/m-gerwing/2010/07/07/housing-in-rural-america
Do poor people in the U.S. live in trailer houses, while those with a little more wealth buy RVs?
View more
Your review makes me want to watch this movie for more than Frances McDormand's acting. It sounds like one of those quiet films that stays with you. Many of us fear losing loved ones or the lives we are used to because we then have to figure out who we are afterwards. It's a hard journey but the message is clear that a person can learn to live differently rather than stop living altogether.
That's why I admire Fern. Her life on the road seems to be her personal way of surviving grief, something I don't think her sister or the woman with the daughters understand. You capture the beauty and sadness of her journey so well in your review. I wouldn't mind an intermittent nomadic lifestyle. It sounds like an adventure. Thanks for sharing. I hope you and your husband are doing well. πΉ
Hello dear @kemmyb,
Do we have to courage to go it alone? I don't know if I would.
I think a nomadic lifestyle would be daunting for me, although maybe that's age talking.
Thank you for asking about my husband. We are doing OK. He is going for his appointments and we always hope for good news. I think one day I will write a blog about how I have his 'office' arranged. He doesn't have to get up much at all. We got him a swivel chair. His closet, beverage refrigerator, desk, TV, computer--just about everything is an arm's length away. All he has to do is swivel--fortunately he has long arms :)))
So glad to hear you're both doing okay and I hope his appointments continue to bring good news. The way you've arranged his office with a swivel chair sounds practical. With everything within arm's reach, he has his own little command centre. π Well done. Do take care.
View more
I never knew what Nomadland was about, though I've heard of it of course, particularly Chloe Zhou's achievement. I might just dig out the movie and watch it now
Nomad is a very unique way of life, either in a van, or often in England, a canal boat. I don't think I can handle that due to the logistics constraints.
I was thinking about how 'real' this was. Most of it is not scripted, but part of it is. Also, once a camera is on the scene, how real is anything? I guess it's the best she could do. I certainly feel I have a sense of what it is to live like that, as a nomad with little resources.
Living on a boat or in a camper sounds a little exotic and charming, if it's a voluntary arrangement and you have a nice boat and camper. But, struggling to eat and get necessities probably gets old very quickly when resources are limited.
Its charming when its like a 30-days tourist experience after which one goes back to his cozy urban apartment.. . when its an everyday struggling for eat and basic resources, suddenly its not. But ofc it can be handy, can be refreshing, appealing - you name it and choose correct option - but still.
View more
My guess its just a very small % of folks have a mindset matching this way of life. 99,9% of folks wanna have roots and feel settled-down.
Actually many people suggest me this movie most of my friends have watched it and said many good things I really must watch it.
I do highly recommend it. Watch it when you in a good mood, because it is rather sad.
This seems like a thoughtful yet sad movie. Now I really want to know if Fern gets a happy ending. I remember Frances McDormand from the sci-fi, Transformers: Dark of the Moon and I remember she was great in that too. Good review.
!discovery
It is a sad movie, and yes, very thoughtful. In a way, though, it's not that sad, because she gets on with her life and she meets good people on the road.
I really think you will enjoy this.
This post was shared and voted inside the discord by the curators team of discovery-it
Join our Community and follow our Curation Trail
Discovery-it is also a Witness, vote for us here
Delegate to us for passive income. Check our 80% fee-back Program
Thank you very much @discovery-it π
Having lived a 'homeless' life in the UK for a time as a new traveller, as my husband had also lived this way before he met me (and loved in an old mobile library when I met him) I always like reading, and watching, stories of people on the road, squatting, or otherwise living in alternative homes. I have quite the stories about it. Van life became trendy and marketable yet people still look down their noses at people forced to live in caravans in encampments around cities in the UK like Bristol. I was holding down a professional job but wouldn't tell anyone we lived in a truck squatting an old bit of disused council land because the stigma was real. Some 'sites' as we called them were full of drugs and booze, some less so. All kinds of people, some people born into the new traveller life, some students, nurses, gardeners, labourers, because rent was expensive and site life gave them instant community. When you live that way community can be the best thing, so that living in a house is suddenly very, very lonely, and the wonder of running water as opposed to 25 l water containers filled up round the back of a church is quite something. A lot of people were forced off sites with various laws - they made it harder and harder to live this life which the government had begun to try to eradicate since they first started as new age travellers in the 1980s. No wonder the new travellers used to mock 'van lifers' who youtubed glamourous conversions when they used to pick up an ancient Bedford and make furniture from materials found in a skip without 20,000 followers to validate them. From counterculture to consumer culture I suppose. Anyway I'm rambling. Too much to condense here. I think I never wanted to watch Nomadland as I felt it would have been too contrived for me and as you say emotionally manipulating. It's always something I was going to get around to.
I think this is more and more automated these days - robots packing in huge factories. Jamie saw Jeff Bezos yacht (or one of?) in real life the other day moored in Qld and it made me want to cancel my Amazon membership. Now there's a disconnect - how the workers earn barely enough to pay rent and Bezos has so many, many bazillions.
I will watch this one day.
I always thought if something happened to Jamie and I lost the house I could happily live in a van. I'd want a brand new Mercedes Sprinter though and not the decrepit things we used to live in. One with a shower and a diesel heater thanks very much. Still, yes, it would be lonely. But you can be lonely in four walls too.
I'm not sure if you can find this anywhere
UNDER COVER - Feature Documentary https://share.google/ZYTCIAruaP7kLmxMC
About homelessness and Australian women. It's a great doco. Homeless women here are far more likely to live in a van - it's safer.
This was our lorry
We had a red Chesterfield sofa and a wood burner.
Oh wow, you were something, weren't you? Where were you when I was setting up house? I had no idea how to be a suburban person, a suburban 'housewife'. Maybe I did know but I didn't care. My mother always did things right. Fine plates, fancy utensils, cut crystal vases. Not me.
My first dinner party--I invited three former colleagues from work. I felt sure they understood who I was. Everyone knew I was 'unconventional'. But no, they were stunned when I put a tablecloth on the floor and served dinner picnic style. We had no furniture at the time. I was stunned that they were stunned. It took a long time for me to put on my proper pretend. I still don't enjoy it. I try never to have guests.
The film really is as genuine as could be, considering there's a camera. A camera changes everything. The people are 'real'. The scenes are definitely real. Nothing contrived there. I think you would enjoy this very much. Just about everyone is down on their luck, and I think the hardship of that does not come home the way it must be living day to day.
Great comment. Thanks. You made my night :)
Every time I shove a heap of clothes in a drawer without folding them, I think of Mum. Luckily she can't see in my drawers. I do tidy up my cutlery drawer when she comes for dinner though, as she often helps tidy up. We make a joke of it - she knows my drawers are chaos though the exterior is harmonious. I do wonder if we reject the fancy and/or expensive because we know it is just show, and we just don't care for such things.
That's wild. I will never forget share houses and chai made in beaten up pans and drunk out of Vegemite glasses or pint glasses stolen from the pub. Your house picnic sounds like my kind of thing. No one I know would have batted an eye.
I'm not good at 'proper pretend' - I cake fake it, but it makes me anxious on the inside. There's always an element of rejection which makes the child in me feel very anxious.
I like my beautiful home and beautiful things, but nothing is expensive and everything curated for MY pleasure and no one else's - hence mismatched mugs and charity shop cutlery (such pretty old cutlery brings me joy!). I find it odd that people care so much about such things.
Our live in vehicles were probably the tidiest and cleanest of everyone's on site though. You can't be raised by two pedantic Virgos and then have a messy dirty truck haha. I'd boil water on the stove to scrub the floors on the weekend and whilst everyone else's truck smelt like dogs and cigarettes, mine was always fresh and tidy haha. Quite a feat in winter in England in a.muddy field haha. No, you can't come in with muddy boots and please smoke outside! Haha.
View more
More information - Support - Reports - Discord
Support engagement with a delegation to topcomment:
50HP - 100HP - 250HP - 500HP - 750HP - 1000HP - 1500HP
As sad as our life itself.
π»πΉ